Author Archives: Danel W. Bachman

Review of Coloe, Mary L. “Raising the Johannine Temple (John 19.19-37).”

Coloe, Mary L.  “Raising the Johannine Temple (John 19.19-37).”  Australian  Biblical Review 28 (2000): 47-58.  [Israel/Herod/New Temple]

Review:  In this article Johannine scholar Mary Coloe adopts and promotes the popular Christian temple “replacement theology.”  She argues that the passage found in John 2:19 at the conclusion of the temple cleansing “action” wherein Jesus says that they will destroy the temple and in three days he will rebuild it, is important to the “plot” of John’s gospel.  John goes to the trouble to tell his readers that Jesus was referring to the destruction of his own body. Continue reading

Abstract of Grassi, Joseph A. “The Five Loaves of the High Priest.”

Grassi, Joseph A.  “The Five Loaves of the High Priest.”  Novum Testamentum 7, no. 2 (1964): 119-22. [Israel/Priesthood/Ritual/Liturgy/Worship]

This brief article suggests that there is a relationship between the story of Jesus’ discussion following eating some wheat plucked on the Sabbath and the story of David’s eating the shewbread.  He justified it in terms of David eating the bread of the presence in 1 Sam. 21:1-6.  Grassi suggests there are a number of parallels between these stories and the multiplication of the loaves in Mk. 6 that lead him to believe the 1 Samuel story may have been used for Eucharistic purposes by the early Church.  The similarities are pointed out by a chart with the stories in parallel columns.  An interesting, but not entirely compelling theory.

Abstract of Roth, Cecil. “The Cleansing of the Temple and Zechariah XIV.21.”

Roth, Cecil.  “The Cleansing of the Temple and Zechariah XIV.21.”  Novum Testamentum 4 (1960): 174-81. [Israel/Herod/Christian]

A strong persistent influence of the prophecies of Zechariah 9-14 is found in the New Testament, especially in Luke.  This article focuses on Zechariah 14:21 which says, “In that day there shall be no more trafficker (lit. ‘Canaanite’) in the House of the Lord of Hosts.” Continue reading

Review of Gaskill, Alonzo L., “The Seal of Melchizedek?”

Gaskill, Alonzo L.  “The Seal of Melchizedek?”  Religious Educator: Perspectives on the Restored Gospel 11, no. 3 (2010): 95-121. [Mormon/Symbolism/Melchizedek]

Through extensive research and regular writing, Alonzo Gaskill is establishing himself as one of Mormonism’s foremost authorities on Gospel symbolism, especially symbols relating to the temple.  In this essay he provides a needed and important corrective to the meaning given by some  Mormons to a symbol found in ancient mosaics. Continue reading

Review of Gaskill, Alonzo L., “Clothed in Holy Garments: The Apparel of the Temple Officiants of Ancient Israel”

Gaskill, Alonzo L.  “Clothed in Holy Garments: The Apparel of the Temple Officiants of Ancient Israel.”  In Ascending the Mountain of the Lord: Temple, Praise, and Worship in the Old Testament, edited by David R. Seely, Jeffrey R. Chadwick, and Matthew J. Grey, 85-104.  The 42d Annual Brigham Young University Sidney B. Sperry Symposium.  Provo, UT: Religious Studies Center, Brigham Young University, 2013.

In this discussion of the symbolism of the priestly clothing Gaskill goes one step further in his ongoing study of biblical and particularly temple symbolism and its application within Mormonism. Continue reading

Abstract of Goldenberg, Robert. “The Destruction of the Jerusalem Temple: Its Meaning and Its Consequences.”

Goldenberg, Robert.  “The Destruction of the Jerusalem Temple: Its Meaning and Its Consequences.”  In The Cambridge History of Judaism, Volume IV, The Late Roman Period, edited by Steven T. Kats, 191-205.  Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006. [Israel/Herod/Destruction]

Review:  In this article author Robert Goldenberg studies the rabbinical literature relative to the destruction of the Jerusalem temple in 70 C.E., but as the following facts show Rabbinic literature has its deficiencies. Continue reading

Abstract of Ricks, Stephen D., and Shirley S. Ricks. “‘With Her Gauzy Veil before Her Face’:” The Veiling of Women in Antiquity.”

Ricks, Stephen D., and Shirley S. Ricks.  “‘With Her Gauzy Veil before Her Face’:” The Veiling of Women in Antiquity.”  In Bountiful Harvest: Essays in Honor of S. Kent Brown, edited by Andrew C. Skinner, D. Morgan Davis, and Carl Griffin, 245-56.  Provo, UT: Neal A. Maxwell Institute for Religious Scholarship, 2011. [Near East/Israel/Sacred Vestments]

Review:  In this brief article Steve and Shirley Ricks survey the use and symbolic meaning of women’s face veils in the ancient Mediterranean and Near Eastern world.  As is apparent from their footnotes, their research is based largely in the work of other scholars.  According to them face veiling was first mentioned in a 13th Century B.C. Assyrian text which specified that veils were restricted to noble women, but was apparently later expanded to include free married women, widows and concubines.  Common women and prostitutes were prohibited from wearing veils. Continue reading

Abstract of Geraty, Lawrence T. “The Jerusalem Temple of the Hebrew Bible in Its Ancient Near Eastern Context.”

Geraty, Lawrence T.  “The Jerusalem Temple of the Hebrew Bible in Its Ancient Near Eastern Context.”  In The Sanctuary and the Atonement: Biblical, Historical, and Theological Studies, edited by Arnold V. Wallenkampf and W. Richard Lesher, 37-66.  Washington, D.C.: The Review and Herald Publishing Association, 1981.  [Israel/Solomon/Second Temple/Canaan]

Abstract:  Given the scholarly notion that Israel’s temple was a syncretic development from older temples in the ancient Near East, this article reviews the fundamentals of Solomon’s Temple along with a short review of non-Israelite temples with the ultimate purpose of comparing and contrasting them. Continue reading

Abstract of Dignas, Beate. Economy of the Sacred in Hellensitic and Roman Asia Minor.

Dignas, Beate.  Economy of the Sacred in Hellensitic and Roman Asia Minor.  Oxford Classical Monographs.  Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002. [Israel/Rome]

Abstract:  This book challenges the idea that sanctuaries in Hellenistic and Roman Asia Minor were fully institutionalised within the cities that hosted them. Examining the forms of interaction between rulers, cities, and sanctuaries, the book proposes a triangular relationship in which the rulers often acted as mediators between differing interests of city and cult. A close analysis of the epigraphical evidence based on inscriptions illustrates that neither the Hellenistic kings nor the representatives of Roman rule appropriated the property of the gods but actively supported the functioning of the sanctuaries and their revenues. The powerful role of the sanctuaries was to a large extent based on economic features, which the sanctuaries possessed precisely because of their religious character. Nevertheless, a study of the finances of the cults reveals frequent problems concerning the upkeep of cults and a particular need to guard the privileges and property of the gods. Their situation oscillated between glut and dearth. When the harmonious identity between city and cult was disturbed, those closely attached to the cult acted on behalf of their domain.

Review of Thiessen, Matthew. Contesting Conversion: Genealogy, Circumcision and Identity in Ancient Judaism and Christianity.

Thiessen, Matthew.  Contesting Conversion: Genealogy, Circumcision and Identity in Ancient Judaism and Christianity.  Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011. [Israel/Ritual/Liturgy/Worship/Covenants]

Review:  In this new book, Matthew Thiessen argues that in the Second Temple Period and even beyond 70 CE the genealogical nature of Jewishness remained contested, even by Jews. Much scholarship suggests that by the Second Temple Period, Jews willingly accepted converts into their midst, and circumcision was the rite through which one became a Jew. With this book, however, Thiessen upsets this consensus among modern scholars and challenges the idea that consensus could be found among ancient Jews and Christians. The main question of his book is how did ancient Jews define their Jewishness? How much of their definition was based on genealogy, and if so, was that genealogy permeable or not? Thiessen argues that Jewish understandings of “Jewishness” were not united nor monolithic, and that many Jews, and even some early followers of Jesus, following biblical precedence, remained adamant that Jewishness was not a choice but an immutable inheritance of a particular people: Israel. Continue reading